Article

When the Prize Replaces the Point

The prize should support the point. It should never become the point.

Share card: When the Prize Replaces the Point, white and orange type on a dark textured plate, BigBeardedGinger.com

Put up a board for the most work orders closed each week and watch what happens to the job that takes half a day to diagnose.

That job sinks to the bottom of the pile, because whoever takes it drops on the board.

Not because boards are evil. Not because people should work for free. Not because a reward automatically ruins a good thing.

Because the prize can become the point, and nobody notices until the prize goes away.

THE QUESTION UNDER THE REWARD

Every reward teaches a lesson. Sometimes it teaches the lesson we intended. Sometimes it teaches people where the loophole is.

A sales team gets praised for the number of calls. People learn to make calls. A family gives a child a prize for every book finished. The child learns to finish books. A community group celebrates the volunteer who stays the latest. People learn to be seen staying late.

Those are results. Are they the results we wanted?

Did customers get the help they needed? Did the child understand a single story? Did the work become easier for the volunteers who come next week?

You can reward the visible part of a job and accidentally make the important part invisible.

We say we want curiosity, then only praise the right answer.

We say we want teamwork, then give the trophy to the person who did the most alone.

We say we want quality, then celebrate a record number of pieces without looking at what came back.

The scoreboard is not lying. We are asking it the wrong question.

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN SOMEBODY ALREADY WANTS TO DO THE THING?

There is a second problem. It is easier to miss because everybody is acting with good intentions.

Researchers have tested this with kids who already loved to draw. Once drawing earned a prize, many of them drew less on their own after the prize was gone.

That does not make every reward bad.

A paycheck is not a compliment. It is compensation for time and work. A fair wage is an obligation, not a clever way to make somebody love a bad job. Bonuses can be useful, especially when the task is necessary and not naturally appealing. Rewards can help people start, persist or meet a clear standard.

But if people are already proud of their craft, a new prize can turn a source of satisfaction into another transaction.

And if the prize pays for the wrong part of the work, you may be buying more of the very behavior you are trying to fix.

THE CRAFTSMAN’S PROBLEM

Picture a repair shop.

One technician enjoys the hard jobs. They like finding the cause, testing the fix and handing back equipment that works. The shop owner wants to recognize the effort, so the shop starts awarding a weekly prize for the most completed work orders.

The board fills up. People move faster.

Now imagine what happens to the job that takes half a day to diagnose properly. It pays the same on the board as a quick adjustment. A technician who takes the hard job may lose the contest before lunch.

Nobody ordered anyone to skip the hard repair. The prize just made the wrong work look more valuable. The quick fix that comes back costs the shop the job twice and costs the customer another day without the machine.

A good owner does not solve this by telling everyone to care more. They ask what the board is teaching.

Maybe the right recognition is the repair that did not come back, the apprentice who learned the diagnosis, or the handoff that saved the next technician from starting at zero. Maybe the board should come down entirely if it makes people compete for points at the expense of a customer.

The owner still needs completed work orders. The customer still expects a working repair. Nobody gets a free pass to take forever.

The change is in what earns attention.

A fast job with a bad result is not a win. A slow job with no clear reason is not automatically craftsmanship. We need to look at the work, not worship either number.

The same thing happens at home the day a kid gets paid per book.

Do not confuse movement with motivation. Do not confuse compliance with ownership.

And do not reward a shortcut, then act surprised when people take it.

THE THREE QUESTIONS THAT SAVE A GOOD REWARD

First: what behavior are we paying attention to?

Be exact. If we celebrate volume, say volume. If we celebrate quality, show how we know. If we want better teamwork, look for the act of helping a teammate succeed, not just the loudest person at the finish.

Second: what happens when the reward disappears?

This is the question most reward systems never face. Does the person still care? Can they still do the work? Do they understand why it matters? A reward that starts a habit can be useful. A reward that becomes the only reason to continue can leave the system weaker than it looks.

Third: who carries the cost we cannot see on the scoreboard?

A contest can make one person faster by pushing cleanup onto the next shift. A school award can give the top students more attention while others stop trying. A sales incentive can create a pile of promises the service team cannot keep.

The reward looks successful until you walk around the corner.

Do not throw away every incentive. Fix the lesson it teaches.

If you read the Brief You Get What You Reward, this is the next step: every board you put up teaches something, and it might not be what you meant.

TEN MINUTES TOMORROW

Pick one reward, prize, score or recognition habit you already use.

Write four lines.

What we say we want.

What earns the reward today.

What important behavior the reward might be pushing aside.

One change we can try without lowering the standard.

Then ask the people receiving the reward whether your four lines match what actually happens. Listen before defending the design.

You do not need a committee. You need one honest look at the connection between what you praise and what you get.

If the reward points at the wrong thing, move the reward. If it has replaced a reason people already cared about, give them room to own the work again.

And if the thing you want is not happening because the job is badly designed, do not put up another prize. Fix the job.

The prize should support the point. It should never become the point.

SOURCES

Source 1, primary research: Mark R. Lepper, David Greene, Richard E. Nisbett, 1973, “Undermining children’s intrinsic interest with extrinsic reward: A test of the ‘overjustification’ hypothesis,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 28(1), 129-137. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0035519 . Original text archived at https://web.mit.edu/curhan/www/docs/Articles/15341_Readings/Motivation/Lepper_et_al_Undermining_Childrens_Intrinsic_Interest.pdf . Children who already liked drawing and expected an award for it later chose to draw less on their own.

Source 2, primary meta-analysis: Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan, 1999, “A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation,” Psychological Bulletin 125(6), 627-668, 128 studies. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.125.6.627 . Author-hosted original https://selfdeterminationtheory.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/1999_DeciKoestnerRyan_Meta.pdf . Across 128 studies, expected tangible rewards lowered people’s own interest in a task, while positive feedback did not.

Source 3, original organizational essay: Steven Kerr, “On the Folly of Rewarding A, While Hoping for B,” Academy of Management Journal 18(4), 1975. https://doi.org/10.2307/255378 . Kerr showed how reward systems pay for one behavior while leaders hope for another.

Source 4, original philosophy: John Dewey, Interest and Effort in Education (1913), https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Interest_and_Effort_in_Education . Also original print Library of Congress https://www.loc.gov/item/13021712/ . Dewey wrote about how interest and effort work together in learning.