Article

Don’t Let Luck Grade the Decision

Same evidence. Same options. Same reasoning. Different truck.

Share card: Don't Let Luck Grade the Decision, white and orange type on a dark textured plate, BigBeardedGinger.com

TWO IDENTICAL DECISIONS. TWO VERY DIFFERENT REVIEWS.

Imagine two supervisors facing the same call.

A supplier misses a shipment. The replacement part is available from two sources. One costs more and gives a firm delivery window. The other costs less but has an uncertain arrival date.

Both supervisors check the same information. Both consider the deadline, the available inventory, and what the team can do while waiting. Both choose the supplier with the firm window.

One part arrives on time. The supervisor is praised for a smart decision.

The other truck breaks down. The part arrives late. The supervisor is asked why they made such a poor decision.

Same evidence. Same options. Same reasoning. Different truck.

The trap is real. We often wait until the result is in before deciding whether the thinking was good. Then we pretend the ending was obvious all along.

If you do that to people, they learn an ugly lesson. Do not make the best call with the information you have. Make the call least likely to get you blamed.

A crew that learns that lesson stops using judgment. A child who learns it stops trying new things. A manager who learns it spends more time building a defense than building a better process.

Luck gets the vote. Learning gets thrown out.

THE TWO CLOCKS

Every decision runs on two clocks.

The first is decision time. What did the person know? What could they reasonably find out? What were the choices, the risks, and the rules? What did they believe would happen, and why?

The second is result time. What actually happened? What did the result cost or create? What new information showed up after the choice?

Both clocks matter. They answer different questions.

Decision time tells you whether the choice was sound.

Result time tells you what the world did with it.

A good process can have a bad outcome. A reckless process can get lucky. Repeated bad outcomes can also tell you your decision method is broken. None of these statements cancels the others.

The trouble begins when we smash the clocks together and ask one question: Did it work?

Picture a sales team. A representative makes a promise that has not been checked with the people who must deliver it. The customer signs. The leader celebrates the close. A month later, the order becomes a mess.

Was the first decision good because the sale came in? No. A win can hide a debt that has not come due.

Now picture someone who refuses to promise a delivery date without checking capacity. The customer goes elsewhere. The representative is told they lacked the hunger to win.

Was that decision automatically bad because the sale was lost? Also no. The team needs to understand whether capacity was checked quickly and accurately, whether alternatives were offered, and whether the customer’s real needs were understood. The lost sale matters. It does not answer every other question.

You cannot teach people to protect the standard on Monday and punish them for protecting it on Tuesday.

WHAT THE RESEARCH SAYS

Researchers tested this in 1988 and again in 2023. Both times, people rated the same decision as smarter when it turned out well. That shows how people judge. It does not prove every leader does it.

If you only review the result, you may reward a risky shortcut and punish the person who made a responsible call.

You get what you reward. But sometimes what you reward is the lucky ending, not the behavior that earned a repeat.

THE BAD CALL THAT WORKED

Picture an event organizer who skips a venue walkthrough because the room looked fine last year. The event runs smoothly. Nobody trips, the power holds, and the guests leave happy.

The organizer says the walkthrough is unnecessary.

That is the dangerous part. A good outcome just became evidence for a bad rule.

The next event has a blocked access route or a missing piece of equipment. Everybody suddenly wants to know why nobody checked.

The pattern shows up everywhere: shortcuts look efficient when the risk stays invisible. The person who skips a step becomes the person who “gets things done.” The person who asks for the check becomes the one “slowing everyone down.”

The lesson is not that every process step is sacred. Some steps deserve to be removed. The lesson is that you remove a step because you understand what it protects and have a better way, not because you got away with skipping it once.

One successful roll of the dice is not a new standard.

THE GOOD CALL THAT LOST

Now turn it around.

Picture a parent who gives a teenager a modest budget for a school project. They talk through the options. The teenager checks prices, chooses materials within the budget, and follows the agreed plan. One purchased item breaks unexpectedly.

If the parent responds by taking the whole project back, what did the teenager learn?

Not budgeting. Not comparison shopping. Not how to recover from a setback.

They learned that ownership was conditional on everything going right.

A better response asks: What did you know when you chose? Was there an avoidable warning? What can you do now? Would you make the same choice next time?

Sometimes the answer will be yes. The choice was reasonable and the result was unlucky.

Sometimes the answer will be no. They overlooked something important. Good. That is a lesson with a handle on it.

This is not a pass for repeated carelessness or a reason to excuse harm. It is a way to find the part the person can actually improve.

A teacher can use the same distinction when a student tries a sound method and still misses the answer. A volunteer coordinator can use it when a carefully planned event gets rained out. A family can use it after a hard decision whose costs were honestly discussed beforehand.

People cannot develop judgment if they are only allowed to own successful outcomes.

THE REVIEW THAT MOVES THE GOALPOSTS

Here is where leaders usually make the damage worse.

Before a decision, the instruction is “Use your judgment.”

After a poor outcome, the instruction becomes “You should have asked me.”

Before a decision, the leader says “Do what is right for the customer.”

After a lost sale, the leader says “I need you to close.”

Before a decision, a parent says “You can choose.”

After a disappointment, the parent says “I knew that was a bad idea.”

There may be a genuine mistake in any of those scenes. But there is another mistake sitting right beside it: the rule changed after the score was posted.

You cannot expect confidence from a person who must guess which rule you will enforce after the fact.

If a decision has boundaries, name them beforehand. Name the money limit, safety stop, customer promise, authority line, or point when another set of eyes is required. State what success looks like beyond the outcome itself.

Then honor the boundary you gave. If it turns out to be a bad boundary, fix the boundary. Do not pretend the person was given a different one.

THE TEN-MINUTE TWO-CLOCK TEST

Choose one decision that is real, uncertain, and safe enough for the person closest to the work to make.

Before the result arrives, write five short lines.

1. The choice. What exactly are we deciding?

2. The facts. What do we know now, and what is still uncertain?

3. The limits. What are we not allowed to trade away?

4. The reason. Why is this choice better than the realistic alternatives?

5. The check. When will we look again, and what would make us change course?

That is the decision-time card. It is not a project charter. It can fit on the back of a work order or in a note on a phone.

After the result, add two more lines.

6. The result. What happened, including harm, cost, delay or benefit?

7. The learning. Did the reasoning hold up? What new fact or better boundary changes the next decision?

Read lines one through five before you argue about line six.

If a poor result reveals a gap in the original reasoning, fix that gap. If the method was sound and an unusual event changed the outcome, strengthen recovery without manufacturing blame. If a lucky result followed a rule-breaking shortcut, do not hand out a trophy for getting away with it.

For high-stakes, regulated, safety-critical or medical choices, use the required professional procedures and competent oversight. This short exercise does not replace them.

WHAT IF THERE IS NO TIME TO WRITE ANYTHING?

Then say the five lines out loud.

“We have two suppliers. One is cheaper, one is more certain. We cannot miss the customer notice deadline. We are choosing the reliable window because recovery time matters. We will check the shipment at noon.”

Thirty seconds gives the next conversation something to stand on. It also gives the person making the call the dignity of clear expectations.

It will not eliminate bad outcomes. That is not the goal. It makes the path to a better next decision visible.

WHEN THE RESULT REALLY DOES MATTER

There is a fair objection: “Customers do not pay us for good intentions.”

Correct.

A broken product still needs repairing. A missed deadline still needs explaining. Harm still deserves an honest response. A failed promise still belongs to somebody.

Accountability for a result is not the same as punishment for a decision.

You can own a bad outcome, make the customer whole where appropriate, and still conclude that the decision was reasonable with the evidence available. You can also celebrate a successful result and decide never to repeat the method that produced it.

When outcomes repeat, use the pattern. If your “reasonable” decisions fail every week, the assumptions, information, options or limits need changing. An unlucky event can explain a single miss. It cannot become a standing excuse.

Do not confuse fairness with softness. Fairness is how you make better standards stick.

FOR THE PERSON LEADING THEMSELVES

Most of us use the same bad scoring system against ourselves.

A choice goes poorly and suddenly we remember every warning as obvious. We turn a difficult situation into a story about being foolish. Or we get lucky and tell ourselves we must have been brilliant.

Neither story teaches much.

Before your next uncertain personal decision, write the reason. Not a speech. Three sentences are enough: what you know, why the choice makes sense, and what would change your mind.

Then, when the result comes, compare your thinking with your record. Keep the lesson. Drop the fantasy that you were supposed to know the future.

You are responsible for the work you put into a choice. You are responsible for dealing with its consequences. You are not responsible for knowing a fact that did not yet exist.

WHAT CHANGES TOMORROW

Take one decision your team made this week. Find the moment it was made.

Do not start with whether it won or lost. Start with what was visible from that moment.

If you praise people only when the gamble works, you will raise gamblers. If you punish people whenever a sound call fails, you will raise people who wait for permission.

Build people who can explain their choices, stay inside real boundaries, own what follows, and improve the next call.

That is the kind of decision-making that survives one bad Tuesday.

A lucky shortcut does not become a standard. An unlucky sound decision does not become a failure of character.

Make the call. Learn from the result. Keep the two clocks separate.

Go deeper: Read the BBG Brief Give People a Decision They Can Make. A guide on what happens when the scoreboard becomes the purpose, Winning: The Losing Strategy, is in the works.

SOURCES

Baron, J., and Hershey, J. C. (1988), “Outcome bias in decision evaluation,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 54(4), 569-579. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.54.4.569

Aiyer, S., Kam, H. C., Ng, K. Y., Young, N. A., Shi, J., and Feldman, G. (2023), “Outcomes Affect Evaluations of Decision Quality,” International Review of Social Psychology, 36(1), 12. https://doi.org/10.5334/irsp.751